December 2024

Browse the archive
202655
202558
202455
202338
202224

Tracking the past and present: notes from my GTLF 2024 panel

We had a great discussion at the “Tracking the Past and Present” panel at the George Town Literary Festival last Sunday, skilfully moderated by accomplished Penang-based author and publisher Keith Hockton. Mike Gibby shared how narratives can be found in many sources, including fascinating stories from the life of Dr. John Bishop King, an East India Company surgeon who lived in mid-19th century Penang. Rexy Prakash Chacko, Penang’s foremost hiking expert and author of two hiking books, regaled us with his adventures in Penang’s highland forests where he encountered ruins of buildings mentioned in historical writings, making history feel tangible and real.

I’m not sure if GTLF will release the panel recording, so for the benefit of those who couldn’t attend, I’ll attempt to recall what was asked and what I replied.

Keith posed these questions to me:

  1. “Can you share an example where a historical narrative has shifted significantly due to modern reinterpretations? What caused this shift?”

I explained that in my view, narratives don’t get reinterpreted but rather new narratives replace older ones as more evidence is unearthed and our understanding of the past becomes clearer.

I shared that fictional narratives are often thought to be malleable and dynamic but in reality it is only so while it is being written. A work of fiction is set in stone when it’s completed. Nothing happening in the real world nor new facts will ever change its narrative. In fact, if its narrative were to change it is no longer the original work. Non-fiction works, in contrast – not just historical works – are living narratives that get refined and replaced with newer narratives when new evidence that increases our understanding is discovered.

For the requested example, I shared recent research I’ve completed regarding the Alexandra Hotel and Baths - a 19th-century hotel of some renown then located near today’s Moon Gate. This research shows the evolution of our understanding of the place, revealing that Princess Alexandra actually endorsed the naming of the hotel and that William Perry Fogg, who was Jules Verne’s inspiration for the fictional hero Phileas Fogg, visited Penang and the hotel. Earlier narratives that often just mentioned the hotel and baths as a passing footnote now have a richer story, thanks to newly discovered writings by Fogg and a French doctor.

  1. “In your opinion, how should we balance the preservation of the ‘original’ context of history with the need to embrace its evolving interpretations?”

I replied that the history of the building where our panel was taking place is a good example. The UAB (United Asian Bank) building, originally a commercial block developed by Yeap Chor Ee specifically for business leasing, is now ThinkCity’s headquarters and a public space for heritage and arts. The original context is preserved in the building’s name. Whenever possible, I suggested, a building’s original context should be documented and remembered through books, information boards on site, and the preservation of original artefacts and architectural features, as demonstrated in the UAB building.

  1. “How do modern reinterpretations and collective memory play a role in this balancing act?”

Having addressed reinterpretations earlier, I focused on collective memory, which I explained is the representation of how a community emotionally processes and remembers significant events - it’s less about precise historical facts and more about shared feelings, experiences, and meanings that bind a community together. The Japanese occupation in WW2, for instance, was a traumatic collective memory for the people of Penang. Even now Penangites tend to automatically attribute any ruins found in the forest and negative historical episodes to the Japanese Occupation. While emotions from collective memory are valid and should be respected, I cautioned that collective memory rarely produces accurate history. For example, most Penangites and school alumni’s collective memory is that St. Xavier’s Institution was bombed by the Japanese. However, I discovered a letter from the Brother Director to Prime Minister Clement Attlee and then-Princess Elizabeth, requesting aid to rebuild the school after American bombing near the end of the war. This new evidence changed the narrative, showing that collective memory can sometimes be inaccurate.

During Q&A, someone rightfully questioned why we were furthering seemingly Eurocentric narratives. The question was directed to Mike and he replied to the person - unfortunately I don’t remember his response. After Mike’s answer, I followed up and explained the time constraints don’t allow us to dive deep into the often multilingual sources. I gave the example of my Alexandra Hotel narrative, which might seem Eurocentric, but it actually draws from American and French sources - parties without political power - and included how Cheah Chen Eok bought the hotel from Europeans and its connection to the Moon Gate. I emphasised that most of my work cites multilingual sources - European, Malay, Chinese, Thai, Indian, and others - and I remain open to incorporating new sources and revising narratives when necessary. I shared William Dalrymple’s advice on this matter:

“It’s absolutely fine for historians to re-examine history. New perspectives are welcome, but they have to be based on primary sources, must be carefully studied, and judiciously interpreted… When new evidence appears, one should be open to reinvestigating the past. But it can’t just be political opinion, nationalistic muscle flexing, or religious bigotry that drives the re-examination of history. It has got to be based on fact, and it should be a fair interpretation of sources.”

https://www.eugenequah.com/blog/tracking-the-past-and-present-notes-from-my-gtlf-2024-panel/

Copyright © 2026 Eugene Quah Ter-Neng. All rights reserved.